Have you an educated heart? — Reading Notes

(0 User reviews)   1775
In Category - Ethics
Burgess, Gelett, 1866-1951 Project Gutenberg 2022 Not confirmed
Conduct of life; Courtesy; Interpersonal relations; Generosity; Kindness Readers of public-domain and historical texts
Project Gutenberg digital edition en

Edition facts

Words 10,593
Reading time 47 min
Text sections 9

The source record for Have you an educated heart? — Reading Notes measures this digital text at 10,593 words, 47 min estimated reading time, and 9 detected text sections.

The text analysis averages about 17.3 words per sentence, while the detected sections provide another way to judge how the source is divided.

Project Gutenberg metadata also associates the work with “Conduct of life,” connecting these edition facts with the source record’s subject description.

Gelett Burgess examines the gap between good intentions and genuine kindness through vignettes like Sadie's ungratefully received gift, arguing that an 'educated heart' requires precise, empathetic attention rather than vague politeness.
Share
Editorial Edition Score 4.5/5

Calculated from edition completeness, EPUB availability, text structure and catalogue metadata. Not a user rating.

How this score is calculated
  • Description quality20 pts
  • Title & short description10 pts
  • Source metadata20 pts
  • Text length15 pts
  • Chapters / structure15 pts
  • EPUB file integrity20 pts

Total of 100 points, scaled to a 2.5-5.0 range. Editions with an empty description or a missing EPUB file are not scored.

Edition quality

Read the Text

she had seen, with those awfully wide black stitchings down the back. Though fairly weak after a bad attack of the flu, poor Sadie had tramped through shop after shop, from 34th Street to 56th Street last week, to find those particular gloves; actually fighting for them, at the last, with a mob of wild women at a bargain sale. Well, Sadie had gone and bought a fancy box. Sadie had wrapped that package with neatness and with fondest care. Sadie had walked twenty-one blocks (so she said) to a Post Office. Sadie had stood there in line for half an hour, more or less, to have it weighed and insured.

“And I just loved it all--I loved doing it for Eldora,” wailed Sadie. “And now all she says is that she is ‘ever so much obliged’!”

“Oh, well,” said I loftily, “we oughtn’t to give things just for the thanks, you know.”

“Never mind the thanks!” snapped Sadie, “but did she _like_ those gloves? Good gracious, you want to know whether you’ve pleased a person or not, don’t you? Were they the right shade? Did they match her gown? Were they the size? Did they fit her? Has she worn them? Why, she might have said _something_ about them!”

“Well, at any rate,” I offered in appeasement, “she answered you promptly. That’s something. Why, loads of people don’t even acknowledge gifts at all, nowadays.”

“Yes, and that’s just the point,” declared Sadie. “I’ve no doubt she thinks she’s really quite polite and kind. Oh, she ‘means well,’ I suppose--they all do. But the trouble with Eldora is simply that she hasn’t got the Educated Heart.”

“The Educated Heart?” I queried, amused, “what d’you mean, the Educated Heart?”

THE lady was growing a little calmer now. “Why, I’ve called it that to myself so long that it seems as if anyone ought to understand. Well, it’s this way. You know you can usually tell an educated man, can’t you? There’s something about him that’s--oh, I don’t know--extra. Finish, it is, perhaps. Distinction, or something. He knows how to--”

“But the Educated Heart!” I insisted, “prithee, the Educated Heart!”

“Why, it’s just the same with hearts as it is with heads,” quoth my Mentor. “Some hearts seem to be self-made, you know--rough-dry--unvarnished--amateurish. And then some hearts are just as if they’d been to college, and been graduated in Kindness. They’ve got their B.K., or D.K., even, sometimes. Yes, I know at least one Doctor of Kindness. Why, I mean, oh, they have that extra touch of consideration--thoughtfulness, you know--imagination--and--oh, dear, why do we like to have flowers on the dinner table? They’re not necessary, of course; but doesn’t that extra touch always make the soup taste perfectly wonderful? It’s all the difference between just eating and dining. Ever see a woman without style jam on a beautiful hat and make it look like a waste-basket? Well, some people are like that, when they try to be kind. Style--that’s what it is! It’s just style in kindness that most people lack. Oh, it’s the rarest thing in the world--the Educated Heart!”

THE Educated Heart! Late that night, alone, I pondered it . . . midnight, and still it haunted me . . . the Educated Heart. . . . Superkindness, she might have called it. She might have called it Tact. Vainly, I tried to coin a new word for it. But at the end, Sadie’s simple term stayed with me--the Educated Heart. And so, using that test, I found myself at length classifying my friends.

And first of all came Crystabel. Last October, you see, I sent Crystabel a book. She acknowledged it, and promptly. But, two months afterward, hadn’t she--yes, she actually had--written me another letter, telling me what she thought of that book; and she proved, moreover, that she had read it--actually read it! Now, reader, I ask you: Isn’t that a strange and beautiful experience in this careless world? Yes, Crystabel had the Educated Heart.

Gelett Burgess opens not with a thesis but with Sadie, a woman who wept at a musical comedy because a friend's thank-you note for carefully chosen gloves said only 'ever so much obliged.' The letter lacked any mention of shade, fit, or whether the gloves had been worn. Burgess uses this small domestic wound to launch a taxonomy of failed kindness—gestures that are technically polite but emotionally hollow.

The book's method is anecdotal rather than abstract. Burgess builds his case through scenes of misdirected generosity, thoughtless listening, and the peculiar human tendency to laugh at others' misfortunes. His target is not cruelty but what he calls 'slipshod sentimentality masquerading as kindness.'

The Anatomy of a Failed Thank-You

The opening anecdote about Sadie and Eldora establishes Burgess's central diagnostic tool: the gap between effort and acknowledgment. Sadie, recovering from flu, tramped from 34th to 56th Street, fought crowds at a bargain sale, walked twenty-one blocks to a post office, and stood in line to insure the package. Eldora's reply—'Ever so much obliged for the birthday package'—contains no reference to the gloves' color, size, or whether they pleased her. Burgess notes that Sadie's distress is not about ingratitude but about uncertainty: 'did she like those gloves?' The letter functions as a kind of emotional dead letter, delivering the fact of receipt but none of the recognition that the gift was meant to convey.

Burgess contrasts this with the 'Educated Heart,' which would have described the gloves' effect, perhaps mentioned wearing them, or at least confirmed the giver's taste. The episode is not presented as a moral failing but as a failure of imagination—a person who 'means well' but cannot inhabit the recipient's perspective.

Listening as a Moral Act

Burgess devotes a long passage to the claim that 'very few people ever really listen.' They perform attention with interjections—'Oh,' 'Ah,' 'Really, is that so?'—but are merely waiting to speak. He offers a test: tell someone you fell down two flights of stairs, and they will laugh; tell them you made ten thousand dollars, and congratulations are faint. The banana-peel joke, he argues, is still the template for how we react to another's pain. 'Unless people see the blood actually streaming, every sufferer is considered merely as a comedian.'

This leads to a provocative corollary: the Educated Heart 'seldom has a keen sense of humor.' Burgess asks readers to consider which friend they would approach to borrow ten dollars—the witty raconteur or the 'serious, kindly dub who never sees the point.' The implication is that humor, as commonly practiced, is a form of emotional distance, a refusal to sit with another's discomfort.

The Grammar of Consideration

Burgess attends to the precise wording of social gestures. The person with an Educated Heart never says 'Now do come and see me, sometime!' because that phrase is understood to mean 'Don't come at all.' Instead, they propose a specific date: 'How about next Wednesday?' Similarly, they never begin a reintroduction with 'Oh, Mr. Spoop, you don't remember me, do you?'—a question that forces the other person to admit forgetfulness—but give their name first.

These are not rules of etiquette in the conventional sense. Burgess is mapping the difference between formulas that soothe the speaker and those that genuinely serve the listener. Even punctuality matters: 'even if only two minutes late a person has brought just that much less of himself.' The book's catalog subjects—courtesy, generosity, kindness—are reframed as a set of small, concrete choices in wording and timing. The 'educated heart' is not a sentimental organ but a trained one, capable of noticing what a routine thank-you leaves out.

Burgess writes in a brisk, aphoristic style that occasionally tips into the arch—'You think I'm fooling? Not at all'—but his examples keep the argument grounded in recognizable social friction. Readers may find themselves testing his observations against their own correspondence and conversations. The book does not offer a program for moral improvement so much as a diagnostic lens: a way to see where good intentions stop and real attention begins.

I keep thinking of Sadie’s gift, how our best intentions can miss the mark. It reminds me of evenings spent with The Phantom World; or, The philosophy of spirits, apparitions, &c, &c. — Reading Companion, where the unseen also demands a patient, careful eye. Both books whisper the same quiet lesson: paying attention is a kind of love, and we rarely do it well.

There are no reviews for this eBook.

0
0 out of 5 (0 User reviews )

Add a Review

Your Rating *
There are no comments for this eBook.

Reader reflection

Before you leave, reflect on the book

Use these questions to collect your thoughts before moving on.

Your progress 0 / 10
1

How far have you progressed with this book?

2

How did the book work for you overall?

3

Would you encourage someone else to read it?

4

How easy was the book to follow?

Related eBooks